Like Santa himself, Tim Gordon and I have made a list, checked it twice, and have found out which Christmas movies are naughty or nice. Tim, as you will remember from Episode 80, is the author of Catholic Republic: How America Will Perish Without Rome and the co-host with Dr. Taylor Marshall on their popular podcast/YouTube channel.
This is a free-wheeling dueling rants about Christmas classics and clunkers from the point of view of cinephilic Catholic dads. Say what you like, but our opinions are correct, I tell you. Well, mine are...
Love, Actually (pornish as is-- use VidAngel!)
A Christmas Carol (George C. Scott)
Disney’s A Christmas Carol (Jim Carrey)
Special mention of the remake of 3:10 To Yuma, no extra charge.
And don’t worry, no Christmas movies involving Tim Allen were mentioned. Shudder. You’re welcome.